Context: Accurate that the court approved the settlement and that Martínez-Olguín's order condemned downloading from pirate sites. But Pallante went on to argue that fair use should not be extended to let tech companies copy copyrighted material for training — and the order decided nothing of the kind. It approved a negotiated settlement, expressly reasoning that "success at trial was not assured"; the only fair-use holding in the case is Alsup's, which found training on lawfully acquired books IS fair use. Characterising the approval as a verdict on fair use overstates what the document holds.